2022-01-28, 05:14 | Link #1 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Somewhere on Earth
|
Mushikaburi-hime (Bibliophile Princess)
Quote:
When book-loving Lady Elianna spots Prince Christopher—her betrothed in name only—consorting with another noble lady, she realizes the recent rumors must be true. The prince has someone he truly loves, which means the annulment of their engagement is both inevitable and fast-approaching. What she doesn't realize is that this is merely a surface ripple—one of many where the truth runs deep, in a conspiracy surpassing her imagination! ANN source https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/new...n-2022/.181977
__________________
|
|
2022-10-06, 21:58 | Link #8 |
User of the "Fast Draw"
|
I don't want to make any presumptions...but man this Irene girl is looking shady . I'd say the scheming "thieving cat" is too common for it to be the case here, but admittedly I haven't seen that actually being used in a while. So honestly it really could be the case here. Mostly since something is definitely off about that girl. It could definitely be coincidence, but I don't think it is. Mostly since Elianna is too nice a person to suspect Irene in that way.
You could easily interpret moments like the book getting ruined as her attempting to make Elianna overreact to demonize her. Most of her actions do fall into the territory of "either she's a really good person that reacts really strongly when she does wrong" or "she's an evil....person trying to use that loud apology to again make Elianna look bad." Although again if no one heard Elianna raise her voice at all then it would seem strange to interpret her as grilling the girl. And it's not like everyone that used to be close to her is acting distant and cold on their own. Either they are just weirdos or she's telling lies to again make Elianna look bad. I don't care how outgoing that girl is. Daughter of a viscount who showed up for some etiquette training is fast moving in on the crown Prince? Yeah... And honestly I don't even think it is just on Irene. Look who turned on Elianna first. The Uncle. Someone who...might want to get some power in that country. He's not next in line so the closest thing would be hand picking his own Queen. Maybe kill his nephew after the wedding...and rule from behind Irene. Heck, maybe that damaged ladder was a flimsy assassination attempt. Elianna is well known to climb all over the place for her books and if they think she's an idiot then maybe he'd think she wouldn't pay attention while climbing the ladder... Honestly this feels like less of a romance story than a political duel from the shadows . Of course I don't think that Irene has that easy a shot at getting the Prince. He's definitely into Elianna as much as she is into him. Yeah, they don't necessarily know how the other person actually feels. But this girl will have to be one heck of a manipulator to get her way. And if she is spreading lies I don't think Christopher is going to buy it. Solid first episode .
__________________
|
2022-10-06, 22:19 | Link #9 |
Senior Member
|
Yeah, there's definitely something fishy going on. I don't know if Irene has anything to do with it, but the uncle and Glen's sudden behavior seems odd.
Even if Irene's been going around spreading rumors I don't know why they'd believe it since they've both known Elianna for about 4 years now. The girl basically just reads and hangs around the prince's office.
__________________
|
2022-10-08, 06:15 | Link #10 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
|
I got the sense that Elianna is so deeply aloof that she's not really paying attention to all the things going on around her.
It creates a rather interesting "Limited First Person POV." To the audience, things are very obviously going on in a mysterious manner, Elianna just isn't inclined to notice, care, or be bothered by them. But on the other hand, when someone asks her something, she responds appropriately and knowledgeably. She knows the names of most of the people surrounding the prince. So perhaps she still pulls in all the information being said around her while she reads, she just never acknowledges it until it becomes necessary? There was also the period where she was barred from the Archives. A whole army of people where in their searching and researching something. Given that Elianna reads on average a book a day? Even rounding down a little, she's probably read 1,200 of those books personally. Primarily a straightforward romance or not, I am deeply intrigued by the mystery they've already been setting up for us to notice. |
2022-10-09, 01:29 | Link #12 |
simp for Lyria
|
Not usually my kind of show, but after watching the Saint's Power is Omnipotent, the taste for the otome-type situation pushed me into watching this.
I enjoyed it; not as interesting a protagonist as the aforementioned series, but the first episode established a sort-of mystery element in Irene. Is she a snake sneaking in, or just really charismatic? Unfortunately, they ruined the "sort-of mystery" element by the comment from the maid; about having to be careful around Irene. Nonetheless, I hope that its a slow burn to find out and not a "Irene and Elianne are alone so Irene's personality does a 180 to find out she's a snake" kind of scenario, because that would be boring as f*k. Elianne's role felt rather limited, but still feels like she develops throughout the episode. At first she only cared about the books, and associating with the various people close to her was just a side job. But over the course of the four years, it seems like their presence is felt just as much as her love for books, so it was interesting to see how it affected her as those elements seemed to be 'taken' away from her. It does feel very one-shot-ish to me though... but so did Shirayukihime's. I'll stick with to see if she evolves as a character enough to keep me interested.
__________________
|
2022-10-09, 05:11 | Link #13 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
|
Reverse harem seems to be cast from the same mould as Hamafura. I guess the Western fairytale prince has to be a blonde, and ironically black-hearted; Chris has just the same bad-boy feeling as Geordo. Still not 'Heathcliffe with blonde hair' tho, since he seems to enjoy himself a lot more.
Eli's role rather than herself seems presently limited; she's a sleepy sweetheart who thinks a bit about what's going on and does her best. This isn't pretending to be especially progressive, so might be good. It was an unreasonable complaint about Bookworm that the kind of books Myne likes are never detailed (her engagement in the bookmaking process and desire to escape into a good book, are substantial, apparent and reasonable). Still nice for Eli interest in history and other cultures to come out, which is actually not bad thing for future queen candidate. Quote:
Last edited by Ghostfriendly; 2022-10-09 at 06:12. |
|
2022-10-09, 05:45 | Link #14 | |
simp for Lyria
|
Quote:
But that wouldn't explain the mood swings of the other prominent characters thus far.
__________________
|
|
2022-10-13, 10:02 | Link #17 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2013
|
Eli thinks her time as a fake fiance and thinks she'll lose the companions and precious life she's found, but while she'll miss the books...deep down she'll miss Christopher and his smile the most .
Don't you just hate it when you finally realize your feelings for someone and then catch them getting chummy with another woman? Poor Eli . "I thought you were with your aunt today!" Christopher just digging himself deeper. Like, that's totally something someone cheating would say, you dunce . Well, at least Eli has her father and brother on her side. They seem to genuinely care about her . Man, Alexei does not mess around. Dude is absolutely savage, even forcing Elianna to work when she just came back to return a book. I don't think that was even part of the plan to catch Irene in her lies, he genuinely just wanted to put Elianna to work . Oh wow, it's kind of surreal getting a proper Otome Game Villainess plot that doesn't involve said Villainess regaining past memories and becoming the Main Heroine! And Irene was not only going to frame Elianna for attacking her but claim Eli was basically bullying her (and poor Elianna has no idea what's going on). But the look on Christopher's face when he knew she was digging herself deeper and when everyone realized Elianna couldn't have pushed her down was priceless . So both Irene and her father are under arrest, and it turns out they were partners-in-crime in this, to the point of trying to assassinate Elianna (and commit other crimes too). Luckily Christopher and co. were able to figure out what was happening and do their best to protect Elianna from them, and effectively expose their crimes. Bonus points by having Alan (Gen Sato!) get all chummy with Irene so he could inevitably turn on her for the big reveal . When it gets right down to it, Irene resented Eli for not being worthy to be Christopher's queen, but that's all the excuse Christopher needed to have everyone extol how great and impactful Elianna has been. She reads a lot of books, ancient ones too, and that gives her the knowledge to actually help out and benefit the kingdom with the stuff she reads about. Elianna is a vital and important individual for the kingdom :nod!: Irene and her father are lead off to face judgement for their crimes, and Christopher manages to secure the loyalty of the one individual left who opposed him marrying Elianna...so it seems like in some respect this was all orchestrated to both expose and arrest Irene and her father while also showing off just how great Elianna is. Because Christopher has been after her ever since their first meeting as kids . I can't wait to meet the queen/Christopher's mother !
__________________
|
2022-10-13, 10:55 | Link #18 |
User of the "Fast Draw"
|
I didn't think that was going to resolve so fast . But that was nice. Although I will criticize the people around Christopher since they weren't exactly doing a good job making Elianna feel comfortable or welcomed. Sure that's sometimes unavoidable. But I feel like some messaging could have been extended so she wasn't left fluttering in the wind like that.
But hey, at least things worked out alright. And in a sense Elianna's position has never been stronger. It was at least a good chance for her to work through her own feelings and that's not a bad thing. And certainly Christopher's legitimate feelings are starting to get through. She convinced herself that it was just a convenience thing and certainly he initially did extend it like that. But it's certainly clear that he never intended on looking at anyone else besides her. Good episode .
__________________
|
2022-10-13, 12:09 | Link #19 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
|
I wanted an anime with such a charming, soft-spoken heroine, who's even much more capable than we thought, to be good. However, an episode of standing about, verbally explaining how great the heroes are and how pathetic the villains, including two characters who haven't even appeared before, was excruciating. The worst thing is that if this was a harem Isekai based on a webnovel first posted on 4chan, it would still have a thread of commenters to defend it.
|
2022-10-13, 12:13 | Link #20 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2013
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
|
|