2004-01-07, 00:49 | Link #21 |
IRC lurker
|
Whom, ever said i was a Naruto "Fan", i watch the show when i have bandwith and time in abudance. I just find it amuzing, i'm not a completely ill-logical and completely mindless Fanbois like some of the Naruto Fanbois
BTW: what i mean by the illogical fanbois, is that the come into channels begging for new naruto episodes the day after the newest one is out. They download from sub groups they've never seen before, whom have it out before the raw is out. And they do many other randomly stupid things that i'm to tired to write. |
2004-01-07, 00:54 | Link #23 | |
Zoro
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Quote:
|
|
2004-01-07, 01:04 | Link #24 |
Weapon of Mass Discussion
Fansubber
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: New York, USA
|
Strangely there is a coherent and important conversation taking place in this accidental thread. I would be remiss in my duties as a moderator if I ignored this. I am going to delete several posts from people who posted nonsense because "this thread is going to be closed." And I am giving them a day's banning to remind them not to be so stupid in the future. This means p3psi gets a day's banning. Worldestroyer and Segahekui get two days because they were also posting flames - I'll be seeing you all soon.
New Topic: This thread has escaped it's creators control. The topic is now discussion of threads that should be closed. We are also bemoaning the loss of the great topics that have existed in the past and discussing why we see few of them these days. Does anyone know why, or can suggest something to revitalize the Naruto forum?
__________________
|
2004-01-07, 01:31 | Link #26 | |
merely a ghost
|
Quote:
At least in my case, I got tired of discussing the same subjects all over again. All these threads we see nowadays have been discussed before the crash, and the thing I most miss is being able to say "... this has been discussed before, used the search button." After discussing the same subject about 50 times, people get tired. At least I do. Discussing about Itachi, the Uchiha clan destruction, Kakashi's Sharingan, Naruto relationship with the 4th Hokage, why we can't assume Itachi is stronger than Orochimaru (that's one I keep repeating in almost all threads). Looks like almost all Naruto subjects were already discussed in the old forum, we need something new to discuss... Like the Nine Demons thread. That's a good one IMO. Maybe the basis is old (about the 9 Great Demons) but it turned out on a thread with new information and discussion. The Kabuto one is other that hasn't been discussed too much on the old forum though. Even though, out of about 100 threads, there's 5 at maximum that's worth discussing. Now IMO, it's obvious that if every nOOb read the Rules and FAQ, this would be a much better forum. It would decrease highly enough the number of stupid and pointless threads- even though they'll never disappear, sadly. There's no other way of making these threads disappear... Unfortanely, almost everyone who posts in this forum for the 1st time don't even bother reading the rules. What can we do? Ban them? Flame them (flaming never work after all)? There's nothing we can do after all, just give the same message "read the rules, this thread is forbidden" and close the thread. The increase in the number of stupid thread is related to the increase of people registering nowadays. A lot of nOObs have come lately, and the majority of the stupid and pointless threads are made by them... But why they do that? Because they don't read the rules. There should be a way of making everyone read the rules before posting for the 1st time... Besides making a thread for the rules, what about an instant PM with the rules of the forum? At least I read all the PMs that are sent to me. Perhaps this way people would read the rules first, and like I said before, the number of stupid threads would decrease. Also, the use of the search button. Almost no nOOb use it. If they did, the number of threads that abroads the same subject as older threads would highly decrease too. But what can we do besides telling them all the time to use the search button? If you want to suggest something, go ahead. We need all the help we can get to revitalize this forum anyways. |
|
2004-01-07, 01:53 | Link #27 |
日本語を食べません!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: San Francisco
Age: 41
|
How about a 'probationary' membership - i.e. you cannot post anything for 48 hours right after joining? If nothing else, it should decrease the amount of 'where can I find the manga' threads, as well as give some people time to read around the forum and get a general idea of how it works/what threads people have posted (at least in the past 2 days).
|
2004-01-07, 01:58 | Link #28 | |
merely a ghost
|
Quote:
Giving time to people read the forums first before posting a thread out of nowhere would help a lot. This way they would know- by reading the threads and (hopefully) the rules- that some kind of threads are forbidden here. Also, how the forum works, as you've said. The forum would get much better this way, I think. Using this new option as well as sending a PM with the rules would work perfectly together. The nOOb would read his PM before posting- even though he wouldn't be able to post. |
|
2004-01-07, 02:28 | Link #29 |
日本語を食べません!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: San Francisco
Age: 41
|
The only downside is that it might decrease the amount of new members - some people join on the spot to post on a thread that they feel they have something major to contribute to, like Sharingan vs Byakugan or the Sannin and why they have the particular animals they do.
I guess there might be a sticky asking people to register even though they won't post just so that when they want to, they can... Also, maybe deleting some inactive accounts would clear up a lot of dead space. It isn't a problem now b/c the forum was reset, but I'm sure there are enough people who join just to ask for manga, and then leave when they realize we aren't going to tell them. |
2004-01-07, 08:55 | Link #30 |
Terabyte needs anime!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Columbus, Ohio
|
Some noobs who may be mostly responsible for the "stupid" threads may not know how to find their answer. They may be brand new to forums and don't understand how to use the search button. (it is our friend) Perhaps a general sticky for how to use it instead of posting a redundant thread may be of benefit?
I also liked that one thread we had for awhile on the first page that members could post simple questions on. Perhaps that could be a sticky? I hate to use someone else thread to use when I have a question (as I have no idea if this is considered rude or not ) but, I hate to start a new thread for all the reasons stated in this thread. Another problem is that (and this has been mentioned before) we have two to three different groups of people on this forum. People who see only the TV series and those who watch the series and are up to date on the Manga. The third group are people like me who Watch, don't read, but highlight every spoiler available. The problem the different groups create is that manga readers grow tired of the Series peoples questions (been there done that-when they read the manga) and that may be annoying. (but they still gracisiously post an answer for all) Then you have really great threads and conversations on manga where series people won't even know who the hell the members are talking about let alone be able to post a decent reply about it. This may be responsible for the "void" one may feel. ? I think one thing that has help is the sticky on the current episode! I love the forum because it drives me nuts to see something and not understand why it can be. Not knowing drives me crazy (short trip yes, but one I'd care not take) I know it's anime, but I come to expect a little more to it and so far it hasn't let me down. Some say "there are plot holes" and I don't want to buy that, as if it becomes overwhelmingly true, I for one, would have to stop watching. It would be so "Sakura" annoying. to watch then. As far a language and punctuation people have to lighten up. If someone claims to be a "perfect" English major fine, then he should post perfect. But this forum is to be fun and informative and young and old don't want to sit hear going "is this spelled right, do I need a colon or a new paragraph for this" to post. If someone doesn't understand they can ask for clarity or if it is worse than that, just don't read their post, shit no one was born perfect, so unless Jesus is here I don't think anyone should crucify anyone for bad grammar. If you can't understand, state you can't understand what someone posted, but to pick on grammar is counter productive. Unless you really need that "pat on the back" to say you are better than someone else, then go right ahead. ah feel the Recently everything is pretty cut and dry in the series so there isn't too much to say perhaps. Last edited by pathyfinder; 2004-01-07 at 09:10. |
2004-01-07, 11:30 | Link #31 | |
だいすきが大好きです!
|
Quote:
and i was wondering why p3psi was banned... i was quite shocked and Inside the FaQ there should be a section (seperate post) that says questions that have been answered and where they have been discussed. That way anyone who posts one of those questions can be punished accordingly and cant claim "wtf?? i didnt know!!!" ... because it was in the FaQ/forum rules. just my 20 billion lira. (.02$) |
|
2004-01-07, 15:00 | Link #32 |
A.S.S. Vice President
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: i dont know can you help me
Age: 34
|
how about moving the search button and making it more obvious like put it on top of the page enlarge it and put a small description there so noobs will know where it is and waht it is before posting stupid stuff and i agree hobo i thinkg the forums being split into spoilers and non spoilers is a great idea because then we wont have to put in tags and warnings all the time *anoying* so is the 48 hours before posting rule i think that will definetly chop down some useless stuff and one more thing how about making it somehow mandatory for the new comers to read 1) the rules 2) the faq and 3) the theads not allowed in the forums
|
2004-01-07, 16:40 | Link #33 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Quote:
It's a lot easier to make a new post then to find an old one about the same topic. Lets say I try finding a Post : Sasuke is the manliest man of all men. If i put "Sasuke" on the search i'll get like dozens of results (I'm just taking wild guesses don't try and actually put Sasuke on the Search and prove me wrong) Then i'll have to look at each "Sasuke" thread, then after i find it I can then place an appropriate post on that thread. Why not just make a new one it's a whole lot simplier. Now there are exceptions, if someone posts something new when the original post is still on the first page, then that guy is just lazy, but if it's on lets say the 3rd page, then why bother trying to find it? |
|
2004-01-07, 17:56 | Link #34 |
Terabyte needs anime!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Columbus, Ohio
|
Perhaps people aren't HARD on "repeat threads" and the like, it's more like ANNOYING. Shit we (should) all try to follow the rules and then someone says "well it's easier and faster if I just start a new thread" after not even trying to find a similar/same thread, then perhaps they should find a new forum. This forum will work at it's best if everyone tries following the rules. Then when they are startled when they get told to try this, and do that, or worse yet get flamed they are upset? Well, you were the one that "two lazy to look on page 2, 3 or 4.
I have no problem with people who tried the search but came up empty but people have to realize that if they really really want an answer then they should care enough to spend some time and look for it instead of cluttering up current discussions. The premise of two Naruto forums would be nice but difficult to facilitate. I like the idea of making the search button more user friendly No one is perfect, but it is obvious that some people don't even try. One day we had the same thread (worded three different ways) on one page!!! Sometimes I wonder if people just do this shit for fun, then come back and say... "The Naruto forum sucks and the members are as gay as the show sucks!". |
2004-01-07, 18:22 | Link #36 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Quote:
i like ur caption that's pretty funny |
|
2004-01-07, 19:04 | Link #37 |
Senior Member
Artist
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Montreal
Age: 43
|
My god.. How did it get to this I meen.. I felt like the forum was getting weird these days but not since that long ago.. Anyway I agree it does need a clean up. Especialy for the stupid theads who must be eliminate the moment they are identified I happen to think ''Somebody please post a clever thread!'' but hey as much as old bored ''sennins'' have nothing less to talk about noobies are noobies and often ignorent not stupid, I mysel in the begining have post threads that I cant stand anymore like DBZ VS Naruto threads. But bless YOUR god I dint get flame by the recurring ''I'm cool'' quote: ''usless thread'' that appears everywhere... post count: 200 ''usless thread'' post count: 201 .. Come one people the key is communication. I'm on for the idea of 48H after register before the first post, but will that realy change everythings? the major probleme will still occur. And I doubt it will ever change with that kind of behaviour.
__________________
|
2004-01-07, 19:15 | Link #38 |
Zoro
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Heres a STUPID, INEFFICIENT idea... but it would work best at getting rid of pointless threads. When a thread is created, a mod/admin must examine it.
This would require lots of mods... so maybe more mods should be hired, but only with the power to examine the creation of new threads? "newbies" shouldnt be allowed to create a thread. After certain amount of post counts they can start creating threads. In Gamefaqs, the less of a newb u are, the more threads u can create in a 24 hr span. So maybe every 25 posts grants u 1 thread every 24 hrs? like i said... this idea is a bit stupid. |
2004-01-07, 19:28 | Link #39 | |
Terabyte needs anime!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Columbus, Ohio
|
Quote:
also: I became a member because I just had a burning question; so I registered and posted a new thread in the same day. "why was Gaara's sand attack brushed away so easily by Gai" ahhhhhhh seams like yesterday.... every person logs on for several reasons, waiting may not help at all, and then again it might? |
|
2004-01-07, 20:14 | Link #40 |
Vandread
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: I LOVE NEW YORK cough* my ass cough*
Age: 37
|
I'm not gonna even bother reading ne more than the first post and this is my reply. Whats happened to the Naruto forums i used to love. I mean I stay away for 2 weeks and its all useless threads like this.....wow.....
Edit: Im surprised this aint closed yet. 2nd Edit: LOL just for the record, anyone want to start the old who is the best out of the 3 legendar sennins (Dranz, Dragonflame.....and.......err.....my bad to whoever this was) thread again? I mean it did receive a lot of flaming but it did make Dranz and Dragonflame post within seconds of each other. |
|
|